As an EP and writer on the project Tomi does have a dog in the fight beyond ego (it seems). There's simply not enough being said right now to make any definitive statements. Rather than leaping to its being done in "bad faith" why not consider is it that bad? How bad must it be for her to not even want to see the final film yet alone promote it? How bad must it be that she couldn't care less about the checks? How bad must it be that *the* goal of a book to film adaptation is now being so thoroughly discarded?
The argument presented here is pro business as usual and just... no. No to corporate entities squeezing the life force out of everything they touch. No to artists constantly having their true visions and intentions ripped away for profit. No. And based on Tomi's thread post this week, that's exactly what she's saying: no more.
So let us be patient and see what actually does come out before immediately jumping to (once again) throwing Black women to the corporate wolves for the simple crime of expressing autonomy.
Well as a creative producer myself I would first say writers very rarely get any say in the creative choices of their adapted material. Unless written into her contract she was naive to think that she would. She’s lucky they didn’t banish her from set from the beginning. But writers of adapted source materials and screenwriters are low man on the creative Decision totem pole. If she is a producer that’s a bit different but again refer to contractual language about creative input in the final product.
So that IS her bad if it wasn’t written in her contract and if it were she would have already lawyered up to file suit, just sayin’ , which is why she took to the media. So that is where the bad faith is. Whether the original beef is right or wrong means nothing when it boils down to contracts. If she tanks it, depending on her contract, she herself could be taken to court and should be on notice not to cross the line.
I do think that a lot of other black people are involve in the project and as we’ve seen are being attacked by fans. I think we might be in agreement on somethings which is we don’t know for sure what happened.
If she will bring it to the open, I think what would have be fair is to tell the public what happened. Let the public also have more information to make a sound conclusion.
In agreement there. We don't know what contracts have been signed either, NDAs and the like. She may be legally barred from saying anything, either indefinitely or until the films release. Again, we simply don't know.
My complaint is about eating jollof rice with okra. People eat jollof rice and okra, just not together in the same plate. It’s not a common practice at all. It is in fact a very weird food combo.
She doesn’t understand how Hollywood works. I know another writer on a different project who briefly worked with her and then quit because she made it too hard to navigate. (Which is fair many novelists don’t like being adapted but then don’t sell your work to the movies and pretend you’re an expert in the craft).
Film and writing for print are two entirely different worlds. One should never assume that to do one well is to be able to do the other one at the same level. Film in particular is the kingpin of group projects. It's never just about the writer, director, EPs etc. All hands on deck, all talents essential. We've all seen projects that didn't translate well because they followed the book too closely. And we've seen films that flopped because they disregarded the book almost entirely. There's a harmony to be struck and it sounds like that didn't happen with this project.
I understand Tomi Adeyami's point. If I wrote a book, and it got popular, I'd be pretty pissed off too if the movie wasn't made my exact way. But I would also have a look into the company offering to adapt my book? No offence to her, or anyone, but there's a lot of things that varies when being signed. Like your Disney comparison. I feel she should've done more research before she even considered getting ger book adapted.
This situation (mind you, I didn't know who she was nor have ever read the book) reminded me of Rachel Zeglar's comments about Snow White and Rick Riordan's attitude to the movies. How they didn't like it and were against the media that was being made. But at least they give reasons. They validated their opinions. This author didn't bother.
I don't even see how this benefits her in any way. Boycotting the movie just because she doesn't like it? That doesn't benefit anyone, except her ego, especially as a black woman when her readers could see the story they empathise with so much. Imagine how validated they would feel saying, "My favourite book is written by a black author, with black characters about [whatever the plot is but I'm assuming it's relevant to race] and it's so popular it's been made into a movie with **black** actors."
I just feel like she's being difficult for no reason. Is there really a reason or is she just being petty and letting someone else get slammed for sticking to the idea they had over the author's book? I feel like she's just doing a disservice to the people who were working on the movie and her readers who were excited for it over what seems to imply a petty reason.
The budget for the film is over $200 million. If it was an indie film or she was a more established film maker who had made successful films and was making the film, she might have had more say. There is just no way the studio will not dictate with that money. They want to make a commercially successful film by all cost because of the money. That is not experiment money.
Also this is just the first one. They bought rights to 2 other books she wrote. I suspect it was a disagreement on set and not really overall direction of the film. But she created a ruckus and then didn’t say what really happened.
I’m still coming back to read this because it’s gold. I knew when she was raving about getting a movie adaptation and I was happy for her. But to read this now??? Wow!
one day yall will stop running to criticize black female creatives especially with takes like these. you do not know the full story. just speculating and yapping. with all the possible conclusions, this is the one you chose 🙄🤦🏿♀️ embarrassing
It’s almost as if you read another post, not this one. You failed to actually engage with any point made in the essay, the main argument which is she should have gone ahead and said what really happened and given the public more information to decide what they think of the matter better since she brought it to the public.
You said nothing about her posting a screenshot of a private conversation she sent to Amandla Sternberg, a black female creative, who has been attacked before potentially opening her to new attacks. You ignored that the author has done this before to another woman and had to apologize. Yet somehow you claim out of thin air I have a history of running to criticize black female creative.
Like I said in my essay, I guess it’s par for the course.
As an EP and writer on the project Tomi does have a dog in the fight beyond ego (it seems). There's simply not enough being said right now to make any definitive statements. Rather than leaping to its being done in "bad faith" why not consider is it that bad? How bad must it be for her to not even want to see the final film yet alone promote it? How bad must it be that she couldn't care less about the checks? How bad must it be that *the* goal of a book to film adaptation is now being so thoroughly discarded?
The argument presented here is pro business as usual and just... no. No to corporate entities squeezing the life force out of everything they touch. No to artists constantly having their true visions and intentions ripped away for profit. No. And based on Tomi's thread post this week, that's exactly what she's saying: no more.
So let us be patient and see what actually does come out before immediately jumping to (once again) throwing Black women to the corporate wolves for the simple crime of expressing autonomy.
Well as a creative producer myself I would first say writers very rarely get any say in the creative choices of their adapted material. Unless written into her contract she was naive to think that she would. She’s lucky they didn’t banish her from set from the beginning. But writers of adapted source materials and screenwriters are low man on the creative Decision totem pole. If she is a producer that’s a bit different but again refer to contractual language about creative input in the final product.
So that IS her bad if it wasn’t written in her contract and if it were she would have already lawyered up to file suit, just sayin’ , which is why she took to the media. So that is where the bad faith is. Whether the original beef is right or wrong means nothing when it boils down to contracts. If she tanks it, depending on her contract, she herself could be taken to court and should be on notice not to cross the line.
Fair.
I do think that a lot of other black people are involve in the project and as we’ve seen are being attacked by fans. I think we might be in agreement on somethings which is we don’t know for sure what happened.
If she will bring it to the open, I think what would have be fair is to tell the public what happened. Let the public also have more information to make a sound conclusion.
In agreement there. We don't know what contracts have been signed either, NDAs and the like. She may be legally barred from saying anything, either indefinitely or until the films release. Again, we simply don't know.
Agreed. I'm a film industry alum and I know how insidious the industry can be. My bias is to trust the IP holder every time.
And the book was sooo 😑. Who eats jollof with okra?
😂😂
People in many parts of West Africa eat jollof rice and okra. I mean, okra comes from there. Why is that so weird to you?
Lol that was quite bold for someone who doesn't live in Nigeria
My complaint is about eating jollof rice with okra. People eat jollof rice and okra, just not together in the same plate. It’s not a common practice at all. It is in fact a very weird food combo.
And I’m Nigerian (hence, West African)
Yeah. It’s not something we do at least in Nigeria.
This is a lie. Those two food items are not complementary.
She doesn’t understand how Hollywood works. I know another writer on a different project who briefly worked with her and then quit because she made it too hard to navigate. (Which is fair many novelists don’t like being adapted but then don’t sell your work to the movies and pretend you’re an expert in the craft).
Film and writing for print are two entirely different worlds. One should never assume that to do one well is to be able to do the other one at the same level. Film in particular is the kingpin of group projects. It's never just about the writer, director, EPs etc. All hands on deck, all talents essential. We've all seen projects that didn't translate well because they followed the book too closely. And we've seen films that flopped because they disregarded the book almost entirely. There's a harmony to be struck and it sounds like that didn't happen with this project.
I understand Tomi Adeyami's point. If I wrote a book, and it got popular, I'd be pretty pissed off too if the movie wasn't made my exact way. But I would also have a look into the company offering to adapt my book? No offence to her, or anyone, but there's a lot of things that varies when being signed. Like your Disney comparison. I feel she should've done more research before she even considered getting ger book adapted.
This situation (mind you, I didn't know who she was nor have ever read the book) reminded me of Rachel Zeglar's comments about Snow White and Rick Riordan's attitude to the movies. How they didn't like it and were against the media that was being made. But at least they give reasons. They validated their opinions. This author didn't bother.
I don't even see how this benefits her in any way. Boycotting the movie just because she doesn't like it? That doesn't benefit anyone, except her ego, especially as a black woman when her readers could see the story they empathise with so much. Imagine how validated they would feel saying, "My favourite book is written by a black author, with black characters about [whatever the plot is but I'm assuming it's relevant to race] and it's so popular it's been made into a movie with **black** actors."
I just feel like she's being difficult for no reason. Is there really a reason or is she just being petty and letting someone else get slammed for sticking to the idea they had over the author's book? I feel like she's just doing a disservice to the people who were working on the movie and her readers who were excited for it over what seems to imply a petty reason.
Thanks so much.
The budget for the film is over $200 million. If it was an indie film or she was a more established film maker who had made successful films and was making the film, she might have had more say. There is just no way the studio will not dictate with that money. They want to make a commercially successful film by all cost because of the money. That is not experiment money.
Also this is just the first one. They bought rights to 2 other books she wrote. I suspect it was a disagreement on set and not really overall direction of the film. But she created a ruckus and then didn’t say what really happened.
After the Nora Roberts incident, I knew I had seen everything I needed to see. None of this surprises me. A whole adult.
Myself likewise was not surprised
What is the Nora Roberts incident?
Here you go: https://www.forbes.com/sites/rachelkramerbussel/2018/12/01/nora-roberts-tomi-adeyemi-title-plagiarism-accusation/
Paywall restriction 🤦
Thanks for the context 👍
With the video that came out, it looks like we're still in the dark as ever.
I’m still coming back to read this because it’s gold. I knew when she was raving about getting a movie adaptation and I was happy for her. But to read this now??? Wow!
one day yall will stop running to criticize black female creatives especially with takes like these. you do not know the full story. just speculating and yapping. with all the possible conclusions, this is the one you chose 🙄🤦🏿♀️ embarrassing
It’s almost as if you read another post, not this one. You failed to actually engage with any point made in the essay, the main argument which is she should have gone ahead and said what really happened and given the public more information to decide what they think of the matter better since she brought it to the public.
You said nothing about her posting a screenshot of a private conversation she sent to Amandla Sternberg, a black female creative, who has been attacked before potentially opening her to new attacks. You ignored that the author has done this before to another woman and had to apologize. Yet somehow you claim out of thin air I have a history of running to criticize black female creative.
Like I said in my essay, I guess it’s par for the course.
Tomi said "glitter" not "grifter" in her message
Thanks. That was an error.
Ooo wow!