The first time I was told I needed to take initiative was at my very first job. As an intern at a media company, I can scarcely remember what the context of the conversation was. But having spent almost a decade working in media and now as a manager, I see that there were many problems with the structure of that company and what it optimised for. I will tell you something I remember from my experience, and you be the judge of what that says about the direction of the leaders of that company.
I was an intern, fresh from university with no real experience. The way you get media jobs is by sending some writing samples and then doing a meeting, a light chat for that very junior role, just to be sure that you actually wrote the article and give them a chance to get to know you better.
On my first day on the job, with no explanation and no insight, one of my managers gave me the login details to the company’s accounts and asked me to get to work. It was sink or swim. No checklists, no guidelines.
What I have come to observe about managers whose feedback is to “take initiative” or a “lack of initiative” is that, fundamentally, there is a problem somewhere in the leadership of the company. There are only a few reasons why that could be recurring feedback. One is that the manager doesn’t know what your job is supposed to be. Though this sounds like a personal failure, it actually isn’t. Many times, people employ experts who know more than they do and hope they will help the company achieve its goals in areas where the founder is clueless.
In that instance, taking initiative would mean helping the company achieve its overarching goals by working hard and creatively. It really means meeting your key performance indicators in the most creative way because you are managing this department. Failure here would not be determined by taking initiative but really by how well the person does their job. If you are an accountant at Afro Adulting, I can tell you for free, I don’t know jack shit about accounting, the tools you need, or how you work. Your job would be to help balance the accounts but also to advise me on the options available in accounting to help achieve your goals. If you didn’t give me this advice, you would have failed in the job because the goals of balancing our books would not have been met, and we would still end the month thinking about the numbers and unable to account for all our spending.
There was a problem in your department, and you didn’t flag it. It really is not about you not taking the initiative to flag it. You just didn’t do a good job because you didn’t optimise for success.
Another time that taking initiative comes up, and in my view, rather too frequently, is when managers offer it as empty feedback that most times makes no sense or just doesn’t apply to the context. This is one of the hallmarks of a manager who likes to blame their downlines for the failure of their department or just leaders with no clear direction. Again, not having a clear direction is not a problem per se. The way this is typically solved is by pulling your team into a meeting and mapping out a direction, and then allowing the managers to help achieve your goals.
What does it mean to not have taken initiative? It really means that there was work that could have been done but was not done because someone had probably been waiting to be told.
If I have a set of KPIs and I have met them by being creative and achieving the goals the company wants to achieve, have I taken initiative? If, for instance, the role of a CMO has changed over time to become more creativity-orientated and less corporate. These days, many CMOs at tech companies host podcasts and shoot YouTube documentaries as part of their marketing. Taking initiative would be suggesting that the company have a podcast or do a mini documentary. It would be pushing for more in-house video production, expanding social media reach, building an online community.
But this is also how any CMO that wants to truly win would win in today’s world. In which case, if your goal as a company is to become the most youth-friendly crypto company and you’ve launched the biggest crypto podcast in the region, you might have helped the company achieve that.
But I do find that people still throw a lack of initiative as feedback, even when talent has done their job by flagging what was not even their job to begin with or an alternative pathway.
I once had a manager who would constantly share work from a rival company that were not even things I was capable of doing or should be doing and flag it as a lack of initiative on my part. Think of it like being an accountant and the founder sharing a Twitter Space that an accountant at a rival company had done, speaking about the new tax laws, for instance. But you probably don’t even know who the social media guy at your company is, and then the manager couches it as you not taking initiative as the reason why you didn’t think of it.
As a manager myself, I have found that my team’s priorities and mine do not always align. Sometimes it is a deliberate attempt by them to do what they think is easier or puts them in a better position. Sometimes they might have spent too much time working on something else or away from actually working and returning to work. Rather than do what is more important, they would do what is easier first to show they have actually been working, leaving us to suffer or miss out on an opportunity. This is not a lack of initiative. This is either a deliberate attempt to gaslight, or it is just pure misalignment. It is a huge red flag if your team does not know what should take priority in your company. It means someone has not told them, and that person might be you.
With interns, I always make sure to tell them what I would like them to prioritise until they are aware of what they should prioritise, and if, for any reason, that order changes, I promptly inform them. If I ever forget to tell them, I count that as a loss, negligence on my part, and move on and make sure to remember to tell them next time. I also do that with more experienced team members as well. It has become second nature to always tell my team what to prioritise when they have multiple tasks to execute.
What I have found is that many times when a “lack of initiative” is cast at someone, what is typically happening is that something is fundamentally wrong at the company, or someone has not communicated what they wanted, which was not what someone should have thought of doing at all and lacked the wherewithal to consider rationally and so chose a dull form of gaslighting. There should be a reason why a task that was supposed to have been done was not done, and if it was not a task that needed to be done, then it was not a priority at the company.
As an undergraduate, I did a programme at Jumia. Once it was raining, and water had trickled into the factory. It was strange and was not something that had happened before. A fleet of air conditioners was standing just beside the area that was being flooded. In a split second, the team, mostly managers and corporate people who had no business in the factory but had only been there for the programme, ran and cleared the ACs from the water that had dripped into the factory.
That is what it means to take initiative, if you ask me.





