“From the hour of their birth, some are marked out for subjection, others for rule.” — Aristotle, Politics
Look at your life and tell me: how great is it? What is the makeup of this life that you live and have come to love so much, for which you will follow the path that you have chosen? Fame? Wealth? Clout? Relevance? A rejection of your own humanity?
In this life that you have chosen to live, what do favourable policies mean to you? Your constant counter-argument to progress — to obvious progress, to better consideration of your interests on the basis of policy, bad or good depending on what you are willing to say at any time — has it been directly responsible for giving you a better life?
When you have said to someone, for instance, “I am not sure what he would do, and why I should vote for him,” the underlying meaning of this is that the life that you live has been carefully considered, and you would not want to rush to make a harsh decision that will drastically change it. In this case, one of the possible conclusions that you might have considered is that the life that you live, based on the policies that have been enacted, is on a trajectory that may be good. And so you have decided to apply caution lest everything that has been achieved through these policies might be reversed, and you do not know how damaging that might be for you and the people that you love.
There is a sense, another sense, different from the one I have laid out above, in which we truly believe that the choices laid before us are something that someone else must consider and offer guidance on. Convince me passionately which is the best option for me and why it is even worth choosing. In other words, there is a sense in which playing the fool is not in itself a sinister hobby of the damned.
Only a few quotes from thinkers in history have captured this state of mind quite like Aristotle in Politics: “For that some should rule and others be ruled is a thing not only necessary, but expedient; from the hour of their birth, some are marked out for subjection, others for rule.”
Aristotle’s criticism is a sharp repudiation of the village fools—those who pretend not to know the intricacies of their lives, how unfair and unjust they are, and then double down, rejecting the quality of life they claim in pursuit of playing the fool. It is clear that Aristotle considered the state of his society, looked at the people who propped it up the most, and wondered why anyone would choose to be a slave. For him, it makes perfect sense only if the choice is out of their control — if it is their destiny to be slaves.
Defending the current state of affairs—even considering opposing policies from ruling parties and the opposition as worthy of debate—implies that life might not be as bad as we think, or that it might be heading in the right direction. When someone says, “Let’s look at his policies, let’s look at his performance, and I will show you how he is on the right track and why you should consider him for a second term,” what this person means is, "Look at your life. Whatever problems or difficulties you might face as a Nigerian are all your fault. If you still live with your parents in your 30s, or do not own a home or a car, and cannot go on holiday, or convert your naira to dollars without feeling ripped off, it is because you are a piece of shit who has refused to get his act together.”
As Nigerians fully enter the election year, this will be the basis of the conversation we will have. It will be about policies, and most likely in this debate about policy, your lived experience in the country will be decentred. You will ultimately become a part of this, and everyone who votes will have made a decision based on this. But if you think the decision is one that you will make because of a false sense of uncertainty, or lack of information, or just because you are a dull fool, then you should think again. Because no one is foolish, and certainly not you. And like the last time you played the fool, foolishness will not save you from the consequences of bad decisions because foolishness is a societal construct.
There is a false sense of delusion that only when we have reached consensus with others can conclusions be drawn about what has truly happened. This is the state in which people who choose to live as slaves all their lives exist. But this is a lie. We do not need to be in agreement for any truth to be true, because the truth-tellers and those who defend the truth are the only ones whom those who were not present at the scene but seek truth will speak to.
Foolishness is a mask. The idea of the foolish man is a myth. It does not exist. Foolishness is a series of bad decisions that we make that then catch up with us. Foolishness is when society brings us to the town square and shames us for these decisions. Foolishness is when everyone is looking at us and laughing at us for those bad decisions that we have made, probably in secret and were always indefensible, but we thought those who matter would never find out.
Most of the time when we play the fool like this, we do it with the hope that it will benefit us in the long run. No man is foolish. But a lot of us choose to play the fool by pretending the choices we make have not been deeply considered.
In an election year, it will be because we have pretended the state of our lives is not what it is. Whether the life we live needs to be changed or not is not a decision that others have to tell you. Playing the fool will be pretending there is uncertainty here, and the options are not clear. It is a decision that you know the answer to. Whether or not you make the right decision for yourself and the people you love will depend on what you think you deserve.
Is this the life of your dreams? Can you provide for your family? Do you have access to healthcare? Can you retire with dignity?
And so I ask you again: how great is your life?






