“My wife is a wicked woman.”
Eavesdropping on the conversations of young men — who could have been in their 30s — I first heard this statement. More than a statement, it is an idea, an expectation, a dog whistle for a group of men who have been sleeping with women who have been trying too hard to get us. It is one of the sacred ways to show camaraderie in the group.
The men were gathered at a bar in the pitch dark of the night. It could have been almost 12. His wife was not really his wife. They had two children together and had been living together, cohabiting, co-parenting. Their parents knew each other. Everyone called her his wife, and everyone called him her husband. He said he had been sleeping in his car for a week because he was tired of fighting.
In many of these relationships, wickedness manifests as punishments that happen in the spur of the moment, but ultimately we have to confront them as the root of our dishevelment, from which it seems impossible to escape.
The man said his wife had broken the headlamp of his car and had gotten into the front seat and fought him for the wheel. She was wicked because she had seized his peace of mind for too long. To the group, he characterised her as crazy and wicked and manipulative and awful and a mistake, his mistake. He said he was going to deal with her.
Sometimes this is how the women-are-manipulative narrative solidifies in the manosphere. But this is not where it starts.
Erotic relationships between men and women in their current form are supposed to be sources of meaningful nourishment.
In human history, this is the first time the uncoupled are being encouraged en masse to pursue love before marriage. Before now, couples would agree to marriages as part of treaties, contracts between families, status symbols, security, etc. In some cases, their very lives depended on it. Love in marriage was the outlier.
By this very nature, the relationship would be manipulative because it hinges on anything but love. People are there for a reason, and they would do what they can to achieve their goals, sometimes at the detriment of their partners.
These relationships are not created to be enjoyed. Husbands have duties. Wives have duties. Each has to, on occasion, put themselves in uncomfortable, at times humiliating, and most often painful experiences to service the altars of these relationships.
How could it not have been toxic for most?
The men who have been brought to this brink — homeless and confused and exhausted — that he would tell strangers the most intimate details of his marriage so publicly, so loudly, are ripe for conversion. “That is how women do. She wants to control you,” an older, middle-aged man offered him advice. In an instant, he goes from “confused man” to “true believer.”
The narrative that women always seek to control and manipulate the men that they lay with is older than marriage as an institution. Yet it is in marriage that it is further reinforced. The demands of marital duties make it ripe for each party to see no other option than to manipulate. And as a much older man now, I have seen this happen.
Consider the story of a couple who are friends, both lovely people, but a couple nonetheless. They had been fighting, and he had been telling his friends his wife was a wicked woman. They had been trying to build a house. She bought the land. But he had sponsored the development, and they had done the decking and were now at roofing level. But they had been fighting, and so he sold the property. A punitive act that happens in the spur of the moment, but ultimately we have to confront as the root of grounding dishevelment, from which it seems impossible to escape.
António Egas Moniz was a Portuguese neurologist whom historians regard as a pioneer of modern psychosurgery. In 1935, he introduced what he called the prefrontal leucotomy, a procedure to treat psychoses by severing neural pathways in the frontal lobes.
But Walter Freeman, who had a medical practice in America, quickly learned of the procedure and renamed it lobotomy, because it involved cutting a part of the frontal lobe.
Moniz later won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for lobotomy in 1949. But as the procedure became more popular, it generated huge criticism. The side effects were sometimes unbearable. Critics said at the time that recipients of the procedure experienced personality changes, memory loss, emotional numbness, and reduced thinking ability. For the critics who campaigned against it, the ends didn’t justify the means. But the idea of personality change and reduced thinking ability remained in our society, allowing lobotomy to become a catchphrase for this.
Years after society has given us permission to marry for love, the ammunition that our forebearers needed to survive in their marriages remains encoded in us, rearing itself until everything we know about the other person is hate.
Thinking of that old indictment of the wife as the wicked woman, I wonder if it is the residue of the fights of our forebearers or if there is any weight to it. Can women be acrimoniously wicked? Yes. But I see no incentive for a wife to show the kind of wickedness that many men have seen in their marriages, other than fighting a war that is not theirs to begin with.
Modern marriages are supposed to be a clean slate for the couple to start their lives in a new, freer, more equal world than man has ever dreamed of. Yet very few relationships feel like a clean slate. For many, it feels like a gated prison. This is because we have allowed society to trick us. It has sold us love as a way to preserve its beloved institution— marriage — but has denied us the performance of love, demanding that we continue to play roles in ways that those for whom marriage was a means to an end did.
It is here that the lobotomy is performed on all of us. This lobotomy wears the face of the girlfriend, when in reality society is the surgeon, wielding the scalpel, cutting, cutting, and cutting our frontal lobes until we forget who we are — homeless, confused, and frustrated — telling strangers at a bar the most intimate details of our marriages.





